State Audit Reveals Nearly 60% of Tennessee Highway Patrol Evidence Reviews Not Properly Completed

several brown cardboard boxes, manila folders, and sealed paper bags stacked unevenly on industrial metal shelving in a quiet municipal storage room with gray c

AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.

  • calendar_today November 18, 2026

Tennessee Highway Patrol's Evidence Procedures Under Scrutiny

The Tennessee Highway Patrol (THP) is facing questions about its evidence management practices following a recent state audit that revealed significant lapses in required review processes. The audit examined how THP collects, maintains, and secures critical evidence such as drugs, firearms, blood alcohol concentration kits, and vehicles.

Audit Findings: Missed Reviews and Weak Oversight

According to the audit, which was presented by Olidia Guevara of the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office to state lawmakers on November 18, 2026, nearly 60% of required evidence reviews were either not performed or not done according to internal guidelines. Specifically, 32% of reviews were not performed at all, while an additional 27% failed to meet the standards set forth in the agency’s evidence manual.

Guevara highlighted these statistics during the presentation, emphasizing that management did not ensure staff carried out the reviews properly. "When the required reviews are not performed, or are not performed properly, management may be less able to identify deficiencies in evidence handling or accountability," she told lawmakers.

Gaps in Evidence Tracking and Documentation

The audit uncovered additional concerns, noting 24 reviews that lacked evidence of completion and four reviews missing crucial details such as the case numbers and evidence types. The report indicated some of these issues arose because THP leaders could not agree on how to interpret or enforce the manual’s requirements. Meanwhile, managers cited time constraints as a barrier to completing reviews as intended.

Security Concerns at Vehicle Storage Lots

Auditors also identified security limitations at THP’s vehicle storage lots, where evidence vehicles are kept. While the report did not specify these risks publicly due to safety concerns, it acknowledged ongoing issues including improper tracking of some evidence vehicles, insufficient debris removal, and mixing of trooper vehicles with those held as evidence. Management told auditors that new facilities are in development to address these lapses, aiming to improve security and provide dedicated spaces for evidence storage.

THP Response and Planned Reforms

THP Colonel Matt Perry responded to the audit, acknowledging the deficiencies but emphasizing that there was no indication of evidence compromise or disappearance. "We have several layers of auditing that is done within our evidence room within our department in general," Perry stated. "Really, our lowest layer wasn’t being done in an appropriate way—wasn’t being done correctly."

Perry confirmed that the agency is taking steps to revise its evidence manual and clarify responsibilities for district captains and evidence custodians regarding evidence reviews. The audit recommended increasing oversight and ensuring clearer staff roles to promote accountability moving forward.

Looking Ahead: Audit Recommendations for THP Oversight

The Comptroller’s Office advised the THP to improve oversight by clarifying staff duties and enhancing management of evidence reviews. As new storage facilities are developed and internal guidelines are updated, the agency aims to address the issues identified in the audit without compromising the integrity of criminal investigations.

Source: wkrn.com.

Recent Posts

Google Ads

add ads here

Hot Categories